Alcatel may not be the best-known smartphone manufacturer, but the company has a long history of making decent phones at affordable prices. One of the latest models is the One Touch Idol S, and the phone's specification certainly makes a good first impression. Even better is the price. At $329 SIM-free, this is a credible rival to the keenly priced Motorola Moto G.
This model isn't as well stocked in Australian stores as its slightly lower-specced Idol Ultra, but it's well worth huinting one down.
 |
| Alcatel One Touch Idol S |
The Idol S is 7.4mm thick and weighs just 110g, which helps make it more desirable than most phones this cheap. We weren't disappointed with build quality, either. It feels just as well made as the tough-feeling Moto G. Our review sample had a fairly uninspiring grey soft touch finish on the rear panel, but it's also available in red and cherry colours for an extra splash of personality.
The phone's 4.7in IPS display certainty has the quality to match the handset's classy chassis, and is a cut above your average budget smartphone screen. With a resolution of 1,280x720 pixels, the screen has a pixel density of 312 pixels-per-inch (PPI), helping text, web pages and app tray icons look perfectly sharp and crisp. The screen has deep blacks and impressive contrast levels, but the screen is slightly cool; whites had a noticeable blueish tinge when we compared the phone side by side with the Moto G. Admittedly, colours in darker shots didn't pop out of the screen quite as much as on the Moto G, but in general use the display still looked vibrant; it's a great screen for the price.
The dual-core 1.2GHz MediaTek MT6577 chipset had no problems running Android 4.2.2; the operating system felt snappy and responsive. We noticed a slight hesitation when swiping through homescreens when we first turned the phone on, but once it was up and running, web browsing was smooth, even on complicated web pages with plenty of nested comments. We found the phone's default web browser was smoother when surfing the web than Google Chrome. With its default browser, the Idol S completed the SunSpider JavaScript benchmark in 1,265ms, compared to 1,787ms in Chrome.
The Idol S can just about handle 3D graphics, but it may not be able to run the latest 3D games very smoothly or at the highest detail levels. Real Racing 3, which sets its detail levels automatically, loaded up with low detail, but ran reasonably well with only an occasional stutter and slowdown. In the 3D Mark Ice Storm test, the Idol S managed a score of 4,400, which is around average for a budget smartphone.
The phone's battery life is fantastic. The Idol S only has a 2,000mAh battery, which is smaller than the Moto G's pack, but we still saw an impressive nine hours, 43 minutes in our continuous video playback test with the screen set to half brightness. This is almost 30 minutes longer than the Moto G, and should be enough to get you through the day on a single charge, with some room to spare.
The 8-megapixel camera is another enticing prospect for those disappointed with the Moto G's average 5-megapixel sensor. It's unusual to see such an elaborate sensor on a $300 smartphone, and we were generally pleased with the quality of our outdoor test shots, taken on an overcast day. Colours were perhaps a little washed out for our liking, but there was plenty of detail present and there was very little noise, even in wide expanses of sky. Pixels didn't clump together in blurry patches too often either, but the phone did struggle to expose the sky. This is a problem we've seen with many smartphones, though, and it doesn't detract from what is otherwise a good camera for an inexpensive phone. The Idol S can also shoot video in Full HD at 30fps, which is much better than the Moto G's maximum quality of 720p.
Our only major concern is the Idol S's lack of storage. It comes with 4GB of internal space, but only 1.96GB is available to the user. This doesn't leave much space for photos or videos, but the phone does have a microSD card slot that can take up to 32GB cards. You'll definitely need to fit a memory card if you intend to install games or carry your music collection around with you. At least Android's storage settings make it easy to switch between onboard and external storage when downloading and installing apps.
The Alcatel One Touch Idol S is a seriously impressive phone for the price. It's a shame there's not more storage space, but its excellent battery life and smart design make it a joy to use. It's hard to choose between this and the Moto G. The Moto G is very slightly faster and has 8GB of internal storage, but there's no microSD card slot, while the Idol S has stingy internal memory but expandable storage. Either one is Recommended.
